Gotta Be Penelopes, LLC

9650 Strickland Rd., Suite 103-240

Raleigh, NC  27615 

(U.S. mail only, not a store front.)

  • Twitter
  • Facebook Social Icon
  • Instagram

Spread The Love, with Gotta Be Penelopes!

Gourmet Pepper Jellies made from fresh ingredients.

New and Featured Products

If you need a customized cutting board or coaster made, email us for a quote!

Our bread boards are now available in 3 different sizes and our coasters are now available in both leather and wood!!

Visit our SHOP page for a complete list of all our products.

It's Finally Here!!
See our online store for details.
Pineapple Habanero

Our gourmet pepper jellies are made from fresh ingredients, unlike others that use artificial sweeteners, high fructose corn syrup and artificial coloring.   The mild and hot are tailored to taste sweet with the right amount of heat for those wanting mild and those wanting the hotter version. 

Best Sellers

Our best selling pepper jelly is our Hot flavor.


If you're someone who enjoys a lot of heat, then you would love our second best selling flavor, Extra Hot! 

Hot Pepper Jelly


Extra Hot Pepper Jelly

Recommendations of Ways to Enjoy Our Pepper Jellies
  • Dip breaded shrimp, chicken, spring/egg rolls & mozzarella sticks

  • Glaze on grilled chicken, chicken wings, fish, shrimp, ham and pork ribs/loins/chops

  • Fill Tostito (scoops) with cream cheese and jelly for a party

  • Use whipped cream cheese in small clear cups with jelly for a party. Serve with short, fat pretzels for dipping.

  • Serve on toasted buttermilk biscuits, bagels, or english muffins with cream cheese

  • Grilled pimento cheese, bacon and pepper jelly on Ciabatta bread

  • Top it on bacon wrapped scallops (see the recipe on my website) or bacon wrapped shrimp